fbpx
Menu

I love you but I'm not in love with you

HomeForumsRelationshipsI love you but I'm not in love with you

New Reply
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #120809
    U
    Participant

    I feel like hearing some advice could help me because no illness hurts like a broken heart. Here’s my story.

    We were in a relationship for a couple of years, loved each other, cared for one another and so on. Until one day she tells me the magic 21’st century girly words “I love you but I’m not in love with you anymore”. The more I loved her, the more she took me for granted and the more I cared for her the more she lost her respect for me. How silly is that? Of course I can understand her behavior because she’s young and immature and being her first love she doesn’t really understand that love evolves over time and butterflies die over time no matter who you’re with and that’s not the reason to break someone’s heart. (I’m 31, she’s 21). In the end it is all about respect and finding someone who loves you for who you are. And of course it is a never ending work to reestablish that spark not only in a relationship but in marriage also. Every relationship needs to be 50/50. Both sides need to put an effort to work things out. I also wasn’t attracted to her like before but I knew she’s the woman I love and I could never leave her nor break her heart. Maybe that’s because I’m older and I know that no matter who I’m with butterflies die over time and love is then based on respect and commitment. I remember at her age, every girl I was with I always thought there was something better outside the relationship but unfortunately there wasn’t and that’s the only thing that thought me to respect the love and women I have even if the spark is gone because in the end love is something bigger than sparks and butterflies. It’s called respect and commitment. Also there are girls who know how to love and appreciate her man and they know that spark is not equals love but respect and commitment is. In the beginning of a relationship you can never know how your partner is going to react in the next couple of years and it is a big risk loving someone today when people are obsessed with social media and don’t appreciate what they have. Sadly but that’s the world we live in today.

    The thing is I know her behavior comes from immaturity but that doesn’t heal my broken heart even after a couple of months.
    I know many people may gone trough this but my question is how do you move on from this because the feeling of loneliness and worthless is devastating. Thank you for your responses.

    #120815
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear U:

    I view your question to be: “how do you move on from.. the feeling of loneliness and worthlessness”?

    You asked the question following a description of a relationship that ended, but the “loneliness and worthlessness” feelings are connected to core beliefs you have had from before you met your ex girlfriend.

    One the logical level of thinking, you figured out why this relationship ended: your ex girlfriend misunderstood love to be equal to ” sparks and butterflies” and you correctly understood that “love is something bigger than sparks and butterflies. It’s called respect and commitment.”

    So, knowing your understanding is correct (and I agree with it) and that her understanding is incorrect, why the devastating feelings of worthlessness?

    Would you like to go deeper into these feelings and examine their origin and how they presently affect your life?

    anita

    #120821
    U
    Participant

    Thank you for your response Anita.

    I’m going trough every post breakup feeling, can’t sleep, can’t eat, can’t concentrate on my work and so on. It’s been a couple of months already. I have friends who also had young and immature girlfriends and ended up married to them and I thought my ex girlfriend would be one of them but sadly I could never know this day would come. That’s the reason I feel lonely and worthless even after knowing things happened because of her immaturity. It’s when the feeling is much stronger then the individual itself. I’m an emotional guy and maybe that’s the reason I feel this way even after having a clear picture of the reason this happened. I also know how she feels because I know her better than she knows herself. She’s scared because she’s aware that she broke my heart but that doesent heal my pain and she’s probably repeating in her mind the famous words “I miss him but I did the right thing”.

    I’m living in a small city in Argentina and the social life here is very low and so is moving on from this situation. I do go out with my friends and I try really hard not to think of it but it’s not so easy because I loved her to the point where I was ready to take a bullet for her and in the end she took all my love for granted.

    I would like to know what it takes to move on from this heartbreaking situation.

    #120824
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear U:

    To move on from your symptoms: “can’t sleep, can’t eat, can’t concentrate on my work and so on”- Try the following, if you’d like:

    Write her a letter, post it here if you want, knowing you will not send it to her. In that letter (post) say goodbye to her. Tell her all the HOPES you had, the life you dreamed of having with her, and say goodbye to that dream. Describe that dream in detail, how you viewed life with her. Post it here?

    anita

    #120837
    Inky
    Participant

    She is not being immature.

    She loves you but is not in love with you. Believe it.

    That is a valid feeling.

    You do not have to agree with being dumped for the relationship to end.

    There is no relationship unless both people want it to be so.

    Leave her alone.

    Perhaps she is not in love with you because she picked up on your projection of her immaturity? Vibrations are real, my friend.

    Inky

    #120845
    U
    Participant

    Of course I left her alone. I have my own pride and it is not right to bother someone who doesn’t want you anymore.

    I could feel that her behaviour came from immaturity because not only her but many women today in their early 20’s think that they will find a man whom they’re going to feel sparks all the way down in years coming by. If you’re old enough you know that’s impossible and love is something bigger than just sparks.

    I respect her decision of course because it is hard for her to know what real love is with me being her first love. She needs to explore things outside on her own and I can understand that because I was also at her age and I kinda remember me having those feelings back then.

    I was just trying to find an answer how to move on from a woman whom I gave all my love and trust because it seems so hard as time goes on.

    Thank you for participating Inky

    #120869
    Isabelle
    Participant

    Hi U,

    A broken heart really does hurt and unfortunately, there is no medicine you can take to make it feel better or make the pain go away. You say that you have been together for a couple of years so it is normal to feel the way you are. You need to give yourself time to heal and move on and build a life without her.You should not base your worthiness on someone else I know it does hurt when you give your all to someone else and it seems like they just throw it away but that does not make YOU worthless it just means you were not compatible or she just didn’t know how to see it or appreciate it. All you can do is take it one day at a time eventually the pain will go away and it will feel better though I know that probably seems impossible to you right now. You do not know what your future holds the next woman you eventually meet could be the one you marry the one who does appreciate all the love you give her someone who sees things the same way you do. Once you meet her, you might find all this pain and heartache was worth it in the end.

    #120899
    Nina Sakura
    Participant

    Dear U,

    I kinda get it. I was in a similar situation except I was the younger person and he was 6 years older. I was just out of college, he had been working full time for several years. So you can understand we had differences in our life understanding and also in our personalities. He found my acceptance of his introverted nature comforting, I was the nurturing type too. His mature outlook kept me grounded. We were considered the “catalogue couple” in terms of compatibility.

    There was only one glitch despite the sparks in the first few months – it did die out, the sparks I mean. That is expected and I was aware of that….what I couldn’t come round to is my desire to think of other guys romantically and even going out of my way to be unfaithful. Over time, all that I liked about him irritated me – be too grew irritated with me as I continued to be miserable and kinda unbearable.

    The question then is – what the heck is the relationship when the love and sparks die?

    I have an answer now after years of being really dumb about love –

    You stay because you choose to, it’s no longer butterflies…no dreamy lala land and you see the person for what they are – great but irritiating too at some points. You know there are options out there but there is something about this one that makes you want to be with them.

    That’s what I was missing – I loved him but I didn’t love him enough to fight for us.

    It’s been a year since we broke up and now over time, he confesses that perhaps it was for the best. We appeared compatible but we wanted different things from life.

    How did he cope though?

    Well be was in pain just like you. And getting busy in his family business back at home helped immensely. The pain does become bearable over time.

    What about me?

    Well, I had already been thinking of ending it months before it ended. So in a way I was more prepared than he was but yeah, I was not entirely myself – somehow prone to sadness, anxiety and I missed him too.

    As cliche as it may sound, I was the bad guy here no doubt but perhaps it was for the best. Falling in love is easy, but staying in love zint. Your ex has a lot to learn before she can make such big commitments.

    The problem wasn’t with you but rather the situation. I rather adore this line from 500 days of summer (movie) :

    “Sometimes when people grow, they grow apart” this is especially true for early twenties

    Watch that movie if it offers you some solace.

    I apologize for this rather monologue about me. I dunno somehow your state reminded me of my ex. I will always have a special place for him in my heart, a respect for him I can’t explain…it’s just that he wasn’t the one for me.

    Regards,
    Nina

    #120910
    U
    Participant

    Nina, thank you for participating on this thread.

    Seems like you felt the same way like my ex now. In time apart you have learned that love is much more than sparks and butterflies. I know she needs to discover those things on her own without me but my God the pain inside me is devastating.

    Funny thing is that I’m kinda afraid to ever trust another woman after this relationship because the girl can be a real sweetheart but in the end you can allways expect those words “I don’t feel the same anymore”.

    What happened during your time apart Nina, did you reach out to him at some point and have you dated other man?

    #120932
    Inky
    Participant

    You keep talking about and mentioning her immaturity.

    Even if that is true, it sounds like she would have broken up with you even if she was very mature.

    Not being in love IS a valid reason for breaking up with someone.

    Also keep in mind that there could be other reasons but she didn’t want to hurt you too deeply.

    #120938
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear U:

    In your original post, you asked: “how do you move on from.. the feeling of loneliness and worthlessness”?

    This is what you wrote about your ex girlfriend on this thread, so far: “silly…young and immature…she doesn’t really understand…obsessed with social media and don’t appreciate what they have….her behavior comes from immaturity…things happened because of her immaturity…I also know how she feels because I know her better than she knows herself…her behaviour came from immaturity…it is hard for her to know what real love is.”

    Here is a key sentence in your thread: “I have friends who also had young and immature girlfriends and ended up married to them and I thought my ex girlfriend would be one of them but sadly I could never know this day would come.”

    Putting it all together: your plan was to marry a “young and immature girlfriend” just like your friends did, so that she will look up to you as superior to her.

    Your feelings of worthlessness predate this relationship and fuel your need to feel superior to her. She may have realized that your: I know best/ I am older and wiser/ I know what real love is, you silly you etc., were condescending and an unpleasant way to live for the rest of her life.

    anita

    #120940
    Nina Sakura
    Participant

    Dear U,

    Of course it will hurt like hell. It hurt me too to hurt him like this but it hurt the relationship more that I was staying on when my heart just wasn’t there. A part of it is immaturity but a huge part of it was the death of love. Accepting that death and moving on from it was something that had to be done. It wasnt easy though – we stayed in touch, I wanted to be there for him but I often cried when I thought of how much I hurt him. But I was resolute because the commitment was truly gone from my part. He would act all normal in the beginning when we texted and then get angry, accusatory and just lash out at me saying I used him etc I wish he understood this wasn’t an easy choice. Now he does thankfully. Keeping distance from eachother and moving forward with our lives has helped.

    I did meet someone else bdw afterwards and thought we were casual initially thanks to some shit circumstances in which we met, we fell in love. He is very different from my ex and it’s been quite a while since we got serious but this time I thought things through before I entered into a new relationship. Though the spark phase is gone now and we have gone long distance, I want to be with him – there is that component which was missing previously that’s there in this relationship.

    Will it last?

    Gosh I hope so, I will try my best but is there a guarantee about feelings from anyone’s side?

    Nope but we gotta take a leap of faith with love. Some love stories arent meant to be but that doesn’t mean there weren’t amazing moments, there weren’t moments of learning.

    Every woman isn’t like your ex – that’s your hurt talking. I know you were hoping you would have the same story as your married buddies but perhaps that’s just what you think you want, it’s not what you need.

    Now you have more clarity and you gotta give yourself the time to heal through the pain, the confused, angry emotions and you will be mad at her for quite a while – some of it will make sense, some of it won’t…

    Time heals things though.

    Let life take its course. You will never know what’s up next.

    Regards
    Nina

    #120941
    U
    Participant

    Dear Anita,

    I never told her words like I’m older I know best. I always carefully kept listening what she had to say and tried to understand her. And of course I do understand that not being in love with someone is a valid reason to break up.

    I never wanted to marry a immature woman but I kept thinking that she will grow up being with me and not being apart from me and she even once told me that she also wanted those things. That’s the main reason I feel this way.

    I wish her the best and she will be always in my heart.
    Maybe it’s pointless for me to try and figure out what’s really on her mind because those feelings are somehow normal in our early 20’s today and I see many other forums have same or similar topics.

    I’ll just try and live with this feeling day by day and hopefully this pain inside me goes away with time and patience.

    #120943
    U
    Participant

    Dear Nina,

    Like you said I also have moments when I’m angry and mad and feel I’ve been used. Other times I feel something else and those feelings are going in circles every day.

    Also thinking of her being with someone else is so painful that I have the feeling that I wasn’t good enough for her. It’s making me feel worthless even knowing I’m not and I have all the qualities one normal guy must have. But of course she has all the rights to date who ever she wants now. On my side of things I somehow feel that If I start dating again it will be like I’m betraying our past love and moments. I know this kind of thinking sounds stupid but that’s the way I’m living it at the moment.

    I want her to be happy even if that means without me and I hope I will be happy and confident again like I was before our break up.

    • This reply was modified 7 years, 11 months ago by U.
    #120955
    Nina Sakura
    Participant

    Dear U,

    These seemingly stupid thoughts are a part of the whole coping process – so don’t be too hard on yourself and take all the time you need.

    This might sound like a strange idea but maybe a trip will help – to sorta get away, think a bit, put your thoughts in order.

    I hope you will be okay soon 🙂

    Regards
    Nina

    Please do post and let me know how you are doing.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 15 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.