Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
PeterParticipant
Hi Jayde
I very much relate to being in the gray area as I find my self torn between wanting to fully engage in life and retreat from it. I suspect all things have their time
Like Joseph Campbell I suspect my “religion” is underlining books. I have always found the right book showing up when I thinking about some question.Ā The book I’m currently reading is by Eric Weiner called ‘Man Seeks God’. He is a travel writer that sets out on a quest to answer some of his own questions he has about his own experiences, or lack of experience. He ends up spending some time in various communities around the world asking some of the questions you may be asking.Ā It very well written and funny. The humor is self deprecating as he is very respectful to others thinking and experiences.
I wonder if you might also enjoy the book. The writer doesn’t go overly deep but he is very well read so there are a great number of passages to underline š … Why do I think you might enjoy the book… I think like me your wondering where you fit. Where you might feel as safe to be yourself as you are when your with your boyfriend. And why it is you find your self annoyed by those that don’t get it and those that seem to have all the answers. Just a thought
Really like your intentionĀ of doing something you truly love each day and fulfilling your soul’s needs. I suspect that will take you were you cannot yet even imagine you wanted to be.
PeterParticipantOne of the challenges of realizing or awaking to the reality that āYouā are not your ego, you are not your body, you are not your thinking, you are not your emotionsā¦ is a detachment from life. If I am no-thing, no-thing matters and as you mentioned that is the Ego attempting to identify it self with an experience of nothing mattering.Ā If āIā am no thing āIā am nothing, and things only matter when “I” matter, when I am ego. – I remain my ego even as I “know” I am not my ego and around and around we go.
On one level this is a problem of language. How can we reflect one our experiences, explain them to ourselves and other without referring to āIā even though we know the Self is not āI. The result is more often then not that instead of a healthy detachment to experiences we fall into indifference to our experiences and depression.
You had the realization that ātaking things personal does not make senseā a kind of detachment that isnāt. What you are describing of your experience is not detachment but indifference. If you (the āIā) donāt care (indifference) about an outcome why bother working towards any goal – your ego asks.
Itās a challenge. The Art of Detachment is to be fully engaged in life, working towards goals that match your truths (as you know then to be in the moment), while not attaching your sense self and identity to the actions or outcomes. i.e. I am a good or bad person because I do this, I am a good person because I hit what I was aiming at, a bad person because I missed.
You can and get to care about the action and outcomes; however, the outcomes or actions do not define you. In this way you open yourself to play. Sure, what you understand as your truths today may change and with them the direction of your actions – learn better, do better – you get to laugh.
In the problem of opposites, which we must come to terms with, is how we measure, judge, divide and doings so make conscious (awaken) is that reality that the opposites donāt exist. Opposites are not independent sides of a coin that can be separated. As we become conscious of detachment we become conscious of attachment. Awaking to the light is also an awakening to the darkness. True Light will always defeat the darkness however light requires energy – movement. Keep moving. The intention of a practice is to not practice, the intention of seeking is finding (yet how many āseekersā would ever label themselves finders).
Once you ask a question you cannot unasked it. Ignorance is bliss but you canāt go back. Frankly life is easier when we identify with our ego and suffer. Righteous anger and taking everything personal can really get the juices flowing. Sure, in the end its exhausting and unhealthy but it can feel so good in the moment. You awakened to the realization that you are not your ego and canāt go back. Itās a loss, even if it leads to becoming more authentic, every loss needs to properly mourned.
Did any of that make sense?
PeterParticipantUnfortunate there is not try only do. Meaning learning how to speak freely requires you do it
It might help to understand whatās behind your fear of speaking freely ā fear of judgment, wanting to belong, accepted, lovedā¦. And you can work on mastering your stories ā insuring you arenāt projecting your fears and such onto those you wish to speak freely with. As well as creating safe space in which to talkā¦ I would recommend the book ācrucial conversationsā as a guide.
Or you if you want to do something right now detach your sense of self from any outcome that speaking freely might result. Can you be ok speaking freely and accepting that those you wish to convince might not agree on keeping the place clean?
If they chose not to clean you have choices
- clean up after them,
- find somewhere else to live
- Get used to living in a dump
- continue to try to convince them you are right and take on the role of mother.
PeterParticipantI enjoy your posts.
When I was 17 there was a moment when I thought I was hip and cool. (I know those words age me) Anyway one day I mentioned to someone just how cool I wasā¦ that was the end of my coolness. It seems if you think your cool youāre not. My thinking on the idea of āEnlightenmentā is the same, if you think, let alone say you are, your probably not.
After the Gautama achieved enlightenment he had a choice to make, end his cycle of ārebirthā and remain in nirvana or return as a Buddha and teach what he knew cannot be taught (only pointed towards). I took from that story that, as you suggest, enlightenment as being in a state of nirvana is not possible as a persistent state of being in life. Ā Perhaps a monk who lives as a hermit meditating 24/7 might come close to this state of enlightened being but only because life is avoided. (It is un likely that Gautama would have become Buddha had he not left his family)
Its always interesting watching someone who says they are enlightened step in dog crap.
āAll things appear and disappear because of the concurrence of causes and conditions. Nothing ever exists entirely alone; everything is in relation to everything else.ā Buddha
āBelieve nothing, no matter where you read it, or who said it, no matter if I have said it, unless it agrees with your own reason and your own common sense.ā Buddha
PeterParticipantTiny Butterfly you break my heart. I very much relate when my mother passed awayā¦ I felt both grief and relief, sadness and shameā¦
Everything you wrote about how your feeling is understandable. We love and we hope and we fear and all these thoughts arise, some that leave us feeling ashamed perhaps that we canāt be as selfless as we imagine we are āsupposedā to be. I donāt think thereās one way where āsupposedā to be or feel.
PeterParticipantYes I very much relate and find it normal that when we think we are putting on a face and are not good enough we are going to lose energy
But trying to put on a face with every person I talk to, trying to understand peopleās emotions, replaying past hurts and other peopleās words in my head, being upset over not being good enough, itās all too much.
Its sounds like youāre an introvert, if so its normal that engaging with others would take more energy.
In Buddhism part of the idea of the middle way is that you enter the flow instead of resisting the flow. It is in when youāre in the flow that you have access to all the energy you need. Ā It is at the extremes that we feel the loss of energy, or expending more energy then we are creating.
Part of the loss of energy your feeling comes from the labels your attaching to the experience ā putting on a face, trying to understand other emotions, replaying the past. Iām exhausted just thinking about it. The good news is you identified the area you need to work on to find a middle way. Is it possible to interact with others without thinking your putting on a face? Do you always have to understand others feelings?Ā Does replaying conversations over and over again help you? Is judging yourself as not being good enough helpful or a mass energy suck?
PeterParticipantshould I just man up and be miserable at the parties or do I have a right to say no without feeling guilty
You of course have a right to say no.
Notice though you are projecting into the future that you will be miserable and guilty, which you probably will be if you look at attending the party of having to āman upā. Ā We create what we fear. That problem isnāt about your relationship but your insecurities, which are impacting your relationship.
That said its important that you hear what your boyfriend is saying to you when he says he doesnāt feel he can invite you to things and participate in his life. How might he be feeling? Could you be ashamed of him? Do you want to be a part of his life? Youāve explained your behavior as not wanting to ruin his night and yet going or not going your creating a negative experience for both of you. Which negative experience has the most weight?
One of the purposes of relationship is to confront our fears and deal with them. Nothing like a relationship to reveal our shadow.
As an introvert I get it. I always feel uncomfortable in large gatherings, yet when I make the effort Iām almost always glad that I had.Ā But it is a effort, and also my problem. As you posted in a Buddhist site I suspect you already know that you need to let go of your concerns of how you imagine others might be thinking of you. In this case you donāt have to imagine you can ask how your boyfriend feels when the two of you go out to visit friends. He may even enjoy staying beside you and helping you engage.
PeterParticipanthi Rye
In my opinion there is nothing more we can ask of others and ourselves is that when we learn better we do better.
The reality of consciousness is that we become conscious in moments of tension – we donāt become conscious of cold until we experience the tension between the experience of cold and hot. Meaning we tend to learn things the hard way.
I know today there is a tendency to judge people base on a single moment, even if that moment happened years ago when we did not know what we know now. But we are more then a single experience, we are more then the sum of our parts. That you could learn and correct your behavior, and your concern with becoming that person again says great deal about you. That to is a part of the whole
Forgiveness is a concept that it more often then not misunderstood, let alone self forgiveness. Its important to remember that forgiveness does not remove responsibility or accountability. Ā A part of forgiveness is making amends when required and this may or may not evolve those that you harmed.Ā Having made the commitment to learn from your past and do better counts. Self forgiveness also involves amends to the self. Just as your experience likely opened you to compassion towards others you need to have compassion for yourself.
I donāt know anyone who doesnāt have a memory that fills them with shame when something triggers it. Its not a great feeling yet it keeps us aware and asking the question of who we are and wish to be and if we are living up to those values.
PeterParticipantWas this your first interactions with you neighbors?
The response your received from the āBuddhist nunsā did not on the surface conform to Buddhist practice or values as I understand them… But Buddhist are human, and as most humans donāt always live up to their values.
Your post reminds me of the stories you hear of someone yelling a someone for not paying attention only to learn that that person just lost their father. We don’t usually know everything that may be influencing a encounter, we like to think we know, but we don’t.
Is it possible you caught your neighbor at a bad time?
The rule of charity states that if there are more then one way of interpreting an interaction and you canāt or donāt want to investigate the intention then chose the most compassionate interpretation.Ā The next step would be to ask your neighbor about the encounter or wish them well and look elsewhere for help.
PeterParticipantHi Christy
I donāt think I would have been strong enough to experience the type of ego death you had.
My journey tends to be through books and I misunderstood the process and instead of healthy detachment ended up in indifference and depression. Itās a subtle difference learning how to fully enter life experience without attaching oneās sense of identity as being the experience.
Today I would say that for me its not so much an ego death but about establishing a relationship with the ego. Noticing when an attachment of the ego to an experience is taking me for a ride.
PeterParticipantAssuming this thread is open dialog
I found my reaction to this statement personally interesting:Ā āDeath is the permanent ending of somethingā
I do and donāt tend to view death in this way. I mean with regards to personal consciousness maybe but organically no.Ā Objectively Death is a transition, not a permanent end, just an end of one state into another. Atoms and molecules breaking down and reforming, never resting, always in motion, even when our motion stops, or our awareness of our motion stops. And symbolically the word death is always associated with transition, an end but also a beginning.
Not sure where Iām going with that, just though it was interesting… Perhaps my feeling that when we let the ego die its more of a transformation? Perhaps that is a permanent ending…yet is it not true that a part of what dies always feeds what come next
PeterParticipantGenerally speaking in the first half of life our task towards individuation is ādoingā ie school, carrier, establish familyā¦. While the second half the task changes to ābeingā
Or if we think in terms of Maslowās Hierarchy of needs:Ā In the first half of life we focus on Physiological, Safety, Social, and Esteem needs and in the second half we look towards Self-actualization and Self-transcendence.
The Midlife Crises occurs when we sense a conflict between our doing and being needs. If one is not conscious of this natural transition, anxiety may arise and you end up buy the red convertible thinking that the purchase of more things is the answer ā itās a midlife crisis when youāre not awake to the change in needs and or try to fix ābeingā by more more ādoingā.Ā If one approaches the transition accepting the anxiety its not long a crisis but a Midlife transition. (How we label things matters)
I noticed from your lists of concerns that most are based on a concern about imagined future ā essentially your feeling the pain to day for an imagined fear of the future.Ā To move forward you may want to work on the list and identify any cognitive distortions and dissonanceās. In this you well be able to identify the real issues behind your anxiety create a plan to deal with them.
PeterParticipantWhat a interesting experience to have before “knowing” what it was all about and understandable terrifying. It reminds me of something Jung said about it taking a strong and healthy ego to allow it die. Its a interesting thought and I suppose that the week ego only pretends to die danger and instead attaches itself to the belief that all (including the I) is meaningless and empty void. Indifference vice non-attachment
For myself I no longer link of the ego as poison or something that has to be overcome but as a useful go between the conscious and unconscious, a necessity of language that allows for contemplation and sharing of experience.Ā Its very difficult to communicate with others or ourselves without using or thinking the word I even as we know āI am not I” (I am) just as āI am not my bodyā but I like having a bodyā¦ its useful. But sometimes I forget š
PeterParticipantResponding to the topic of ego death
Coming to the realization that āI am not my beliefsā does not necessary mean oneās beliefs are void or that one is indifferent to them, only that one understands them for what they are and so not attached to them.Ā This form of non-attachment creates space where one no longer experience anxiety when a ābeliefā is challenged, which they will be. By non-attachment one can confront the present moment experience that may contradict the belief without danger to ones āidentityā and doing so learn and grow.
Associating and attaching one sense identity with oneās beliefs often leads to depression and or fanaticism. For example, if I am my ego, I am my beliefs this āIā is unlikely to be able to tolerate those beliefs being questioned as doing so puts in question my identity. This such a āIā cannot allow and so āIā will force everyone (and my self) to adhere to my beliefsā¦ even if they no longer match my experiences. (I am divided and divided unhappy)
Allowing the belief that āI am my egoā to ādieā (which is what the ego wants but also fears) one is better able to enter into the experience and ābeā in the moment. (vice the past ā future)
PeterParticipantEvery moment, infinity small, infinity large, every breath we take is a death and rebirth šĀ every breath every moment a reincarnation.
The ego has its role to play in consciousness and easy to mistake for the self and in charge.
āWhat had the experienceā,Ā āI had the experienceā…Ā But the I does not exist – other then a construct of language, there is only the present experience.
- This reply was modified 6 years, 6 months ago by Peter.
-
AuthorPosts