
“Resistance keeps you stuck. Surrender immediately opens you to the greater intelligence that is vaster than the human mind, and it can then express itself through you. So through surrender often you find circumstances changing.” ~Eckhart Tolle
I took a deep breath, feeling the recent change in my belly. I pinched at my belly rolls. They were familiar, I’d had them before, but recently I had gone through a period of over a year where I was in a smaller body. Now I was gaining weight again.
I refuse to step on the scale, so I don’t actually know how much weight I’ve gained. I can just feel it in the extra belly rolls and the snugness in some of my clothes. In my mind, I have two choices: to wage war on my body or to surrender to the weight gain.
Surrender is the ability to let go of the crushing weight of societal and personal expectations. It’s waving the white flag, signifying I’m giving up all the diet culture methods I’ve tried so hard to make work. I’m acknowledging that they actually never worked in the first place. This option isn’t always so easy, though.
For some context, I’m a body positive and fat positive activist. I advocate for acceptance and health at every size. I tell others they’re worthwhile just as they are. Though when it comes time to put them into practice within myself, it’s very challenging.
I still have days where I suck in my stomach, hoping to appear skinnier to the world and to myself. I try to shrink to become small enough. I feel as though my worth lies in the number on the scale (even though I’m a stranger to it now).
I lie to myself and say that I’m never going to find a partner if I keep gaining weight. I beat myself up about the food I’ve consumed and I compare myself to other people.
My body positive journey is far from perfect; I struggle with all of these things. One big reason is internalized weight stigma or fatphobia. It infests my mind and can take over if I’m not careful.
I mean, look at the world: We fear and despise fat. People are bullied and discriminated against because of being in larger bodies. Fatphobia is very real. It’s ingrained subconsciously; our society trains us to be this way.
The Body is not an Apology outlines some ways in which fatphobia rears its ugly head. In jobs, fat employees tend to be paid less for the same work. In dating, they often deal with people who fetishize them rather than seeing them as humans. In fashion, there are rarely sizes available beyond a size 16. In medicine, doctors see them as weak-willed and lazy.
This is not surrender in our society. This is bullying and prejudice. No wonder it’s hard for people to accept their changing bodies—there are so many consequences for being fat.
The irony of fat-shaming in the name of health is that it actually causes adverse health effects. According to a survey done by Esquire magazine, two-thirds of people report they’d rather be dead than fat. Can you imagine the damage this amount of stress does to one’s system?
No wonder we’re terrified of gaining weight. We let those messages infiltrate our minds, and they drive us to pinch at our belly rolls as if we’re the worst people ever.
On the other hand, being thin means being accepted, flying under the radar, even being complimented. It means that life is easier because you’re not oppressed in this way. Still, fatphobia manages to creep into all of our minds.
When you’re scared to death of what other people are going to think of you, you’re carrying your own sense of internalized fatphobia. This phenomenon even impacts those who are in smaller bodies because of the negative feelings they have about themselves and the world.
It makes sense, then, that my first reaction to my body admittedly isn’t always unconditional love. Rather, the old messages in my mind were saying, “You’re not good enough. You’re disgusting. No one will ever love you. You’re a failure.” They were loud and unrelenting. I was familiar with these messages.
For many years I waged war with myself. I was stuck in cycles of binging and restricting that wreaked havoc on my body. I thought I was being “healthy,” but really I was very sick.
I was obsessing over every little thing I consumed, making sure to track seventy-two calories of butter to my MyFitnessPal app and being hysterical when I gave into a Twix bar. Weight control owned me. I was constantly thinking about food.
Binging and restricting create terrible health risks—getting physically sick from too much or not enough food and brittle hair, not to mention the emotional consequences that occur like stress, obsession, and the absence of joy.
I loathed my very existence, and I definitely was fighting a war against my body and myself. I thought that there was something fundamentally wrong with me. It was utterly exhausting.
I started to think that there had to be another way to relate to my body.
When I was twenty-two, I discovered the body positivity movement. I began with a program called Bawdy Love, which was all about being a revolution to loudly declare that every body is worthy and no body is shameful.
I began to follow body positive influencers online like Megan Jayne Crabbe, Tess Holiday, Roz the Diva, Jes Baker, and hashtags like #allbodiesaregoodbodies. Fat women filled my feed. They were beautiful and unapologetic. They taught me that fat isn’t bad and that people in larger bodies aren’t lazy, unhealthy, or unlovable.
Now, I must say, I’m in a smaller body. I have privileges that many people do not. My level of weight gain so far is still keeping me in a body that’s relatively accepted by society. I don’t know what it’s like to face discrimination based on my size.
I do, however, know what it’s like to hate your body and think that you’re broken. I know what it’s like to do the opposite of surrender. When I’m living this way I do things like workout until I’m ill, take my favorite foods out of my diet, and berate my body in front of other people. This is what waging war looks like.
Instead of doing this, I chose to surrender to weight gain. I make this choice every single day. I try to let go of my expectations and preconceived notions. I’m throwing my hands up in the air.
This isn’t a happily-ever-after story where everything is perfect. Rather, body acceptance takes rigorous work as well simply just letting myself be.
I’m continuing to enjoy my food free from disordered eating. This means no restricting; every single food is available at any time. You won’t hear me talking poorly about my body or about anyone else’s. I refuse to diet and I refuse to indulge others in their diets.
To counteract the voices that tell me I’m not good enough, refute them with “You’re worthy and lovable just as you are. Weight is just a number. You’re okay.”
Eventually, I started to believe these thoughts are true. Part of me thinks that maybe, just maybe, my existence on this planet isn’t for nothing. In letting go of the self-pity, a beautiful sense of self begins to bloom.
Surrendering is harder than you may believe. Internalized weight bias runs deep.
I think at times I come off as someone who’s super-confident in myself and in my relationship with my body, but it takes a whole lot of work to get to the point of surrender. The point of being free from the grips of diet culture.
I still poke at my belly, but mostly it’s with curiosity. If I feel disgust, I quickly try to turn my thoughts around to have compassion and confidence. I notice when my thighs are pressed against a bench. I smile, feeling thankful that my legs move me around.
I don’t step on the scale because I know that it can’t tell me anything about my worth. The numbers are irrelevant. I open my arms to weight gain, though sometimes taking a deep breath first. Accepting it means healing from a disordered relationship with my body and food.
Weight gain is an indicator that I’m living with joy in my life. I’m enjoying meals out with friends, snacking on treats at work, and taking seconds. I’m eating when I’m hungry, what a revelation.
I’m taking deep care of myself, and that may not look like other people’s definitions of self-care. That’s okay.
Fatphobia may say that I’m being stupid, but I choose surrender today. For me, that means throwing out lifelong conceptions that I’m not good enough. It means no longer running in circles chasing my tail, trying to lose weight. It’s opening up to the idea that there’s another way to go about this. It’s peace and joy.
About Ginelle Testa
Ginelle Testa is a passionate wordsmith. She's a queer gal whose passions include recovery/sobriety, social justice, body positivity, and intersectional feminism. In the rare moments she isn't writing, you can find her doing yin yoga, thrifting eclectic attire, and imperfectly practicing Buddhism. She has a memoir coming out with She Writes Press in September 2024. You can find her on Instagram.











Though I run this site, it is not mine. It's ours. It's not about me. It's about us. Your stories and your wisdom are just as meaningful as mine.
I appreciate and encourage self love in all forms. However I think it is dangerous to throw up the hands to weight gain and make comments about how ‘almost everyone fails at losing weight’… as if we are all better off to not pay attention to maintaining a healthy body because it’s too hard on the mind. If you are over the suggested weight for your body type and height you are increasing your risk for injury and disease. Please keep things like that in mind before advocating body positivity at ALL sizes. In some cases, people really should be a bit more critical of themselves in order to become better. Not to meet any standard but for their own health and well being.
Anyways, I did enjoy your writing. The article was written very pleasantly and I’d be open to read your thoughts on other topics. I simply wanted to express my feelings on this.
Thank you so much for this article! It really helped ground me on why I started intuitive eating again in the first place. I don’t want to fight my body anymore. My weight has settled at a place that feels good for my body and let’s me be active in the ways I want. That’s a blessing in many ways. The idea of surrender is one I’ll keep in mind.
It’s always a pleasant surprise to me how the Tiny Buddha stories could have come from my own heart if I was a great writer. So thanks for speaking my truth for me!! This article really rings true for me. The more I fight myself over diet, the worse I do and it all become cyclic. Surrender is the HARDEST thing to do because of the fear of losing control and becoming ‘FAT’. But magically, surrender actually works. In my experience, it doesn’t lead to a huge weight gain; once you give in and accept not being perfect, you eat poorly sometimes, but your actions equalize and settle. Thanks for sharing your insight. I loved it!
Thank you. This popped up on a day when I needed the confirmation of my own thought process. Love when the universe does that.
I am all for body acceptance and body positivity at every size. However, surrendering to weight gain makes it sound like it is something inevitable and out of your control. Loving your own body means accepting all the imperfections or ‘belly rolls’ but also caring for it enough to continuously work to maintain good health.
There isn’t only one other option to obsessive dieting (which this article claims to be surrendering to weight gain). There is balance – eating whole foods, moderation of unhealthy treats and plenty of exercise.
Both approaches outlined here seems extreme and shows that the writer has an unhealthy relationship with food. Instead of accepting the inevitable, the relationship with food must be questioned. A person with a healthy relationship with food sees it as fuel, nourishment and energy and is in tune with their body’s nutritional needs.
Sometimes it is easier to bury your head in the sand because you are doing what you want and it feels good. But like in most situations, short-term enjoyment does not outweigh long-term accomplishments.
True love for your body is when you treat it well.
I have had a similar experience. I have struggled with my weight for years, as well as with my emotions about it. Two years ago, I reached a size where for the first time, people started commenting on it. These were not well-meaning people who knew me or cared about me. These were strangers who wanted me to feel their disgust toward me. Last summer, I started working out and avoiding added sugar because diabetes runs in my family and I want to lower my risk of developing it. Some who are anti-body positivity might say, “Exactly! This proves our point!” But it doesn’t. So many people who claim they care about health actually just feel entitled to force others to look a certain way and enjoy putting others down to build themselves up. I decided for MYSELF based on a detailed knowledge of my own body, habits, and family history to experiment with some changes. It was a personal, well-informed decision. It would have been impossible for a stranged, even an honestly concerned one, to have this knowledge about me or make these decisions for me. I also still have to fight body shame. I consider it a separate issue from my personal health goals. I still catch myself thinking, “I am fat.” It feels so hurtful when I think that. I know some have reclaimed that term for themselves, but I can’t. It makes me feel better to challenge the validity of the term’s existence. It’s such an imprecise word, clearly not designed to be a measure of weight to give a person guidance. It’s a mean word to suggest a person is ugly, worthless, and undeserving of love. I remind myself that extra pounds on my frame do not make me a worthless human being. I am deserving of love. I am worthwhile. I am valuable. Numbers on a scale do not determine my worth.
Also, none of us decide to say what ‘healthy’ is. Science does. And always will.
True love for your body IS when you treat it well! The problem is treating your body well and being thin are not one in the same and we live in a society where it is assumed to be. I was thin my whole life until recently. However, I did NOT love my body. In fact, I hated it. I literally starved it. Constantly berated myself for wanting food and would drink coffee all day and wine all night to curve my appetite. I was not treating my body well. I was trying desperately to be thin. When I hit my mid 40’s, something changed. My metabolism slowed drastically, hormones shifted, and at the same time I lost the motivation to eat nothing but a protein bar all day until my little dinner of lean meat and vegetable at night. I wanted to eat. And I still hated my body as it started to gain weight. Then, something shifted. As I started to eat “normal” for the first time in my life I was able to focus on “healthy” eating. I started to love my body and fed it things that were good for it. I did not lose weight and become thin again, but I loved myself enough to be healthy. To stop crash dieting and eat what was good for my body and I learned to love whatever shape my body took as a result…and I loved that! THAT is true body love. It goes beyond what you actually look like and recognizes the importance lies in how you feel! THAT is why being THIN doesn’t matter and should stop being a goal and societal focus. Thin does not mean healthy!!!
In Body of Truth: How Science, History, and Culture Drive Our Obsession with Weight – and What We Can Do About It, author Harriet Brown cites statistics that show over 45 million Americans will go on a diet at some point each year. All but 5% of them will gain the weight back in a year, and all but 3% of them will gain the weight back plus some extra in three years.
Losing weight and sustaining it is near impossible. Almost everyone fails. Just because my approach to food is different than yours doesn’t mean it’s “unhealthy,” whatever that word even means. You don’t get to define what’s universally healthy. I get to define that for myself.
I’ll take my short-term enjoyment over your idea of a long-term accomplishment all day, every day.
Wow, there seems to be a lot of negative assumptions about the author in this comment. Are you a nutritionist? Physician? Dietitian? I hope you realize that comments like these are not helpful, they’re hurtful. Weight is an extremely personal issue that everyone deals with in their own, unique way. There is no “one size fits all” solution to health, wellness and nutrition. What works for some does not necessarily work for others.
My question to you would be: why not accept that people are allowed to make their own choices and live their lives the way they think is best? Do their choices have any impact on your life at all? Why did you take the time to write out these negative, unsupported assumptions about the author? Can you acknowledge the fact that your definition of “love for your body” may differ from someone else’s, and that’s okay?
You never know what a person is going through. It’s always better to be kind than critical.
And one more which is more recent (2019 study):
Julie Slyby, Savannah Mckenna, Justin Mitchell, Silvana Duran Ortiz, Jonathan Young, Yanrong Qian, Darlene Berryman, John Kopchick, Edward List, SUN-094 Altering Cycle Duration Of A Yoyo-diet Has No Effect On Mortality In Weight Cycled Mice, Journal of the Endocrine Society, Volume 3, Issue Supplement_1, April-May 2019, SUN–094, https://doi.org/10.1210/js.2019-SUN-094
I respect how you want to live your life and I am not making a personal attack. This article is about physical weight gain, so I shared my observation. As a professional writer, I am sure you understand that you will be open to critique.
In my opinion, I believe that if you are using a blog as a platform to share ideas, this is a dangerous one. You are responsible for spreading your message of course, but a message which promotes complacency and an indifference to health is something I cannot get on board with. Physical health is just as important as mental health, both are intertwined, and rearranging a mental narrative to suit unhealthy habits and behaviours is clever, but not a solution.
‘Losing weight and sustaining it is near impossible’, can’t say that is true for me. I was overweight most of my life and now I have maintained a healthy weight for the past eight years.
Your stats are based on America (0.05% of total world population), a country in the middle of an obesity crisis. Far-East countries like China (28% of total world population) is an example of where obesity is rare, so I don’t think your comment really applies here.
More stats here: https://www.who.int/gho/ncd/risk_factors/overweight/en/
I still believe in body acceptance at every size – because everyone deserves love and acceptance. This is not a criticism on any particular individual’s size or weight, nor is this a value judgement. It is up to oneself to assign such meaning and worth to their weight that they find my comments offensive.
Science never lies, that is the beauty of it. And ignoring science is a sure way to end up unhappy.
And you’re obviously not “for body acceptance and body postivity at every size.” Your acceptance is conditional on what you deem is healthy and appropriate. That’s not how it works.
Not sure why you beg to differ because I agree with you. Like I said in my original post, ‘dieting’ is unhealthy and usually leads to disordered eating.
In terms of science, I will share some peer-reviewed papers published in scientific journals which cover how dieting does not have an impact on subsequent metabolic rate:
‘We found no evidence that weight cycling, as measured by either of these variables, was associated at baseline with a reduced resting metabolic rate or an increased percentage of body fat. Nor did we find that weight cycling was associated with smaller weight losses in a prospective trial in which subjects were treated by very-low-calorie diet and behavior therapy.’
T A Wadden, S Baertlett, K A Letizia, G D Foster, A J Stunkard, A Conill. Relationship of dieting history to resting metabolic rate, body composition, eating behavior, and subsequent weight loss. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, Volume 56, Issue 1, July 1992, Pages 203S–208S
Another paper outlining the risks of cancer with obesity which has been well-established in multiple randomised controlled trials (RCTs) which is the gold standard for research studies:
Franca Bianchini, Rudolf Kaaks, Harri Vainio. Overweight, obesity, and cancer risk. The Lancet Oncology. Volume 3, Issue 9, September 2002, Pages 565-574.
I will be happy to share more if interested.
I beg to differ on the science. The Health at Every Size Movement has a lot to say on this one: https://lindabacon.org/_resources/resources-dietitians-foodies-2/
You should also check out Chris Sandel’s blog and podcasts on health. He’s a real nutritional science nerd and has spent many years working with people who diet and is aware of how it’s made them unhealthy in so many ways. http://www.seven-health.com/
I’m not saying we shouldn’t eat healthy food, but if you listen to Chris’s podcasts, and read other material about intuitive eating, you will discover that eventually after breaking dieting, people stop craving lots of junk food and rather their bodies tell them what to eat. Most people eat junk food after dieting because they’ve been restricting themselves for so long and junk food is high in calories – it’s a natural physiological response. And it’s actually good because at that point, they need calories more than anything else.
http://www.seven-health.com/2015/09/food-quality-versus-quantity/
But eventually, as their bodies heal, they go back to a more balanced diet and start craving healthier foods. It’s restriction that messes us up and teaches us not to listen to our bodies natural signals like hunger, thirst, fullness, etc.
http://www.seven-health.com/2018/08/restriction-impacts-health/
And the other thing, mental health is a hugely important thing! Having an unhealthy relationship with food and restricting yourself, does not help a mind to be healthy.
It’s respect at every size not healthy at every size. If u are healthy being bigger does not mean that everyone who is obese is healthy.
Nice, well presented.