“Judgments prevent us from seeing the good that lies beyond appearances.” ~Wayne Dyer
When I first took up meditation, sitting with my thoughts didn’t come naturally. At the time, I was going through a divorce and was often anxious and stressed out. It took months, but I kept trying, and after a while I looked forward to my daily sit.
In my meditation group, I learned a classic method for generating compassion and equanimity. I tried holding images in my mind of a friend, an enemy, and a stranger.
The idea was to view each one without judgment or preference, but no matter how hard I tried, I couldn’t seem to generate compassion for my enemy—especially when the face I envisioned was my ex-husband’s.
At last, my divorce was final. Another year passed and I met a great guy. We dated for more than a year before he moved in. Our relationship was going so well that we decided to take a big step together: We adopted a stray kitten.
The kitten was adorable and cuddly and rambunctious. We loved her immediately and she made herself right at home.
A week or so after the kitten’s arrival, I sat down to meditate in my sunny meditation room. It was one of those days where everything felt right with the world. I lit my candles and incense, positioned myself comfortably, and set the timer.
Focusing on the candle’s flame, I breathed in … and out … in and out—but something was terribly wrong. Every breath brought me closer to a distinct reality: I was sitting in cat pee!
I hopped up and stripped the slipcovers off the pillows. Lugging the fouled material to the laundry closet, I angrily muttered, “If we had not taken in this stray, I’d be tranquil right now! That cat has ruined my entire day!”
Then I my thoughts turned to blame. “My boyfriend was the one who wanted to adopt this cat! I should have said no, but I wanted to please him. I should have known better!”
And finally, I took out my frustration on the feline offender: “Some cats just can’t be house trained! If that kitten does this again, she’s going back to the pound!”
I seethed on and on, piling up blame and resentments, turning my anger and dissatisfaction over and over in my head.
If ever there was a good time to practice compassion and forgiveness, this was it. But rather than sitting in meditation, I spent the next hour dowsing the slipcovers and cushions with diluted bleach.
In the days that followed, when I sat down to meditate, I contemplated the kitten’s offense. Then a thought occurred to me that made me laugh. My resentment melted as I realized how ridiculous I was to blame a cat … for being a cat!
The kitten was not a “bad” cat at all. The kitten didn’t pee on my cushion out of spite or because she hated me. She peed on the cushion because she was marking her territory, which is what cats do. It’s her nature.
The kitten was, in fact, being a very “good” cat. The kitten wasn’t the problem. The problem was my expectation of the kitten to behave in a manner that was not natural to her.
Of course, accepting my cat is a cat is one thing. It’s a little more difficult when I try to let go of my expectation of human beings, particularly the one I was previously married to. And yet, how often did I expect people in my life to respond in ways that were not natural to them?
Turns out my kitten taught me more about generating compassion than the guru at my local meditation center. Here’s what I’ve learned from my most enlightening “sit.”
1. It’s called human nature for a reason.
If I can accept that my kitten is just enacting her cat nature, then why can’t I see that my ex-husband (or anyone for that matter) is just following his or her human nature?
Alexander Pope was right when he said, “To err is human.” Since human nature is distinguished by ego, delusions, fears, and a little thing called mortality, most of us are perfectly imperfect human beings.
Too often, I judge myself and others through a warped lens of perfectionism. My ex was (and is) just doing his best to avoid suffering and find happiness—just like me. And like me, he responds out of his limited perspective, experience, and fear. My problem with him is not that he’s who he is; my problem is that he’s not who I want him to be.
2. It’s (not) all about me.
No matter how long I sit on the meditation cushion and try to “generate compassion” for someone, I will never get far if I am still judging that person by my own limited viewpoint. Taking things personally creates a barrier between me and other people, or between my idea of an outcome and reality.
I limit my own perspective when I say, “You have done this to me because you are trying to harm me.” If I can take a step back, I may realize that I don’t know everything about the situation. Only then may I be able to discern that there could be a motive beyond one that’s directly related to me.
3. I’m not okay, you’re not okay.
When I’m angry and upset about an outcome, I often forget that the person who I feel “let me down” is probably also upset and disappointed. Although I may initially personalize a situation, I can use my feelings to identify with someone else’s perspective.
For example, when my son brings home a less than stellar grade that’s upsetting to me, I can be fairly certain that he’s bummed about the grade, too. Realizing that he is equally—if not more—disappointed than I am can temper my reaction and might even inspire a more compassionate response.
4. Consider the parts, not the sum.
No situation or being arrives full-blown without dependence upon mitigating circumstances. (This is also called dependent origination or dependent co-arising.) For example, the traffic jam did not occur because the Universe is conspiring to make me late for work.
The more I can accept that I am a part of a bigger experience, the more I can let go of the importance I place on myself or any given event. Then, I can let go of blaming and see that we are all in this traffic jam (called life) together.
As it turned out, my most dissatisfying meditation session taught me far more about compassion than sitting for hours in tranquility ever could.
Simply contemplating that everyone wants happiness doesn’t get me very far when I’m stuck in traffic or disputing a finance charge on my credit card with a less-than helpful customer service representative.
No matter how long I sit on the meditation cushion and try to “generate compassion” for someone, I will never get far if I am still judging that person by my own limited viewpoint.
Woman with heart image via Shutterstock

About Brigid Elsken Galloway
Brigid Elsken Galloway is a journalist and editor who’s reported for NPR and contributes to various publications and websites. She is also on the faculty of the Institute for Conscious Being. This fall, Brigid published her first collection of essays, entitled The Nature of Things: Twenty-four Stories About Embracing Reality. She blogs at Adventures of a Southern Buddhist Catholic.
Thanks for making me smile and remember not to place so much weight on “the perfect outcome” — it’s usually the messed up moments that bring laughter and lessons!
Wow, this article is timely beyond all reason. I just got home from work. As I left this morning, I passed the communal picnic table in my complex’s dog run; it’s usually taken over by a varying cast of unemployed 19-20 y/o’s who like to smoke various substances and loudly drop F-bombs on each other.
Two girls were out there this morning, having cigarettes. One looked over her shoulder at me, stared, then whispered to her friend; they both sat there, tense and silent, except for the other one muttering something like “But I’m not doing anything!” So I guess (perhaps because I’m of a certain age…?), I’m apparently a narc now or something.
I practiced grounding and letting go of the resulting resentful, wronged, well-fuck-you-too feelings at work, including as I came home (and two other girls stared fearfully at me as I passed). Who needs this drama, especially from people I’ve never spoken to or about?
This article was especially refreshing after today’s events. I am still learning to trust and realize not every snide remark escalates into a blood feud. Maybe holding this article’s message in my mind this evening will help with that.
Thanks buddhabelly! You are so right! The moment I saw my own foolishness, it was as though a little light went on inside me. Keeping my sense of humor about life is key!
Hi Shari! Glad the story was helpful to you. It’s so great that you could apply your mindfulness practices to that situation! As someone who was once young, loud, obnoxious and unemployed, I might hazard another guess of what those girls really thought, “She has it made.” Now at age 50+ I would not want to go back to that time in my life for anything. My 20s were a very difficult. I smoked because I was anxious and worried — often about what other people thought of me. Fear does drive us to do and say hurtful things. Bravo for letting your feelings of resentment go!
Great insights!!! Thank you for sharing your wisdom! 🙂
I really love this; I am printing and saving. When I read your reactions to the kitten, I recognized the exact attitude I was having about a youth I mentor. And your later insight about the kitten fit so completely it hit me right in the guy: “The kitten was, in fact, being a very “good” cat. The kitten wasn’t the problem. The problem was my expectation of the kitten to behave in a manner that was not natural to her.”
The youth has experienced alot of trauma, and I have studied the impacts of trauma although I lose sight of those studies in the face of behavior that frustrates me. But my trauma training makes exactly your point. I am going to use this story to bring me into the right frame of mind next time I feel like quitting!
Great, great post.
I really love this; I am printing and saving. When I read your reactions to the kitten, I recognized the exact attitude I was having about a youth I mentor. And your later insight about the kitten fit so completely it hit me right in the gut: “The kitten was, in fact, being a very “good” cat. The kitten wasn’t the problem. The problem was my expectation of the kitten to behave in a manner that was not natural to her.”
The youth has experienced alot of trauma, and I have studied the impacts of trauma although I lose sight of those studies in the face of behavior that frustrates me. But my trauma training makes exactly your point. I am going to use this story to bring me into the right frame of mind next time I feel like quitting!
Great, great post.
Thank you for your kind words. This lesson has been a real gift to me, and I’m so glad I could share it with you. And thank YOU for the work you are doing.
Thank you!
Hahahaha! I laughed out loud when I read the cat peed on the cushion. My cat used to do that. The poor thing used to really feel my wrath. Too bad I couldn’t see her cat nature at the time. I understand what you’re saying about applying that to other humans. I’m overly critical and take things personally, so everything you write makes sense to me except where you say, “Simply contemplating that everyone wants happiness doesn’t get me very far when I’m stuck in traffic or disputing a finance charge on my credit card with a less-than helpful customer service representative.No matter how long I sit on the meditation cushion and try to “generate compassion” for someone, I will never get far if I am still judging that person by my own limited viewpoint.” I contemplate everyone wanting happiness and try to generate compassion for those who I feel have wronged me. But why don’t these approaches work?
Thanks for this post! Really good stuff to contemplate and apply to my life!
Hi Ellie! Glad you enjoyed the post. I do think many people can (and do) meditate on compassion and are able to find insight into their resentments, etc. It just wasn’t working for me until I was given a very tangible way of seeing another perspective. I used to sit and envision other people who bothered me. I knew intellectually that I should feel equanimity towards them, but could not put it into practice. It took a very visual, real example to jump start my deeper understanding. Hope that makes sense. And thanks again for the kind words!
It occurs to me, upon reading your insightful article, that “practicing compassion” is oh-so-much easier when dealing with an adorable rescued kitty cat who is truly just acting natural…or a child who, let’s face it, may or may not be bummed out about a certain bad grade…. than it is when dealing with a spouse (ex or otherwise). So don’t be too hard on yourself as you work towards letting that resentment go and continue to move forward.
I find that I have compassion and empathy to spare when it comes to my children. I don’t waste
energy stressing about strangers who might complicate my day or traffic jams that slow me down. I’m a pretty level headed person. But my expectations run very high when it comes to the man that I married. I can’t be quick to judge and my irritability is not easily masked. No one can get to me like he can…in good ways and in bad. I need to remember what you say in your piece “Taking things personally creates a barrier between me and other people, or between my idea of an outcome and reality.” I may have to write that one down and keep it handy!!
Yep, that totally makes sense! Thanks for responding and thanks again for helping me with my perspective!
edit “I can be quick to judge”
Hey Marge, thanks for your post. There’s a great saying I heard a few years ago: “An unrealistic expectation is a premeditated resentment.” (Or as Anne Lamott puts it, “Expectations are resentments under construction.”) I’m with you. My expectations run highest when it comes to those closest to me. Guess I’m being given lots of opportunities to practice letting go! So glad you found this essay helpful.
Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I can really relate to it because I am going thru it too.
Now I am thinking about the above, and how I can manage my own expectations
I wouldn’t worry about young people these days! They have a lot more pressure on them than we did when we were their age! I get stares all the time from young people with distrust in their eyes. When I meet a young person that has a great personality that wants to talk to me I find it refreshing.
Thank you! Would love to hear if/how these ideas work in your life.
Great words to live by. Thanks for your thoughtful post and reminding us to expand the aperture. Looking forward to your next one!
I love your phrase “expand the aperture”! My mind is very myopic when I feel wronged. Thanks for your kind words — and great analogy!
Excellent post Brigid. Over time, I have tried a method wherein I focus on my breath and ask myself “What is it in me which is making me judge this person/situation?”. Most of the times, I do get a reply. Sometimes, it is avoidance of taking responsibility for my feelings- “I am reacting this way only because that person is behaving a particular way”. Once I come back to my point of view, I am able to change the place from where the judgment is coming from- for example if someone cuts me in a line at a grocery store, I would react to it because I would feel cheated. I would judge the person as inconsiderate because of the way they made me feel. Ultimately it comes down to me and why people are able to elicit a reaction/judgment out of me.
One of the quotes by Wayne Dyer which might be relevant here is ” How people treat you is their karma. How you react is yours.” This puts things into perspective a lot of times.
Thanks again for the post. It got me thinking :).
Great observations, Neetkia! That Dyer quote is absolutely relevant. Isn’t in interesting how people and situations that trigger our negative emotions really get our attention; whereas sweet, peaceful people and events often go by unnoticed? After what I called “the cat pee incident,” I found myself considering another familiar piece of wisdom, “My enemy is my greatest teacher.” Not that the kitten was my enemy, of course, but in that benign context, dealing with a negative situation gave me a chance to see my response in a way I previously overlooked. Lately, I’ve been working with Rick Hanson’s practice of “taking in the positive” when I have a pleasant experience. I try to give as much time and space in my mind to the person who allows me to go ahead in line as to the person who cuts in front of me. Funny how positive response takes effort, but negative is almost automatic. Thanks for getting me thinking too!
Love the Wayne Dyer quote and your perspective!