Home→Forums→Relationships→My Father Stole My Money and I Started to Hate Him
- This topic has 27 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 11 months ago by Sam.
-
AuthorPosts
-
October 2, 2016 at 10:00 am #116933SamParticipant
Thank you for taking the time to read my story.
I am a 35 years old guy from the Middle East and my relationship with my father has recently started to take a very bad turn and a nose-dive. Naturally like in our culture I trusted my father like no one else in the whole world but recently I discovered that he was deceiving me and has actually stolen all my savings of hundreds of thousands of dollars.It all started 7 years ago when I found a good paying job overseas as a software architect. I worked in big multi-national company abroad for about 4 years. At the same time my father back home retired from his job and started a big project for our middle-income family. The project was a multi-story building in a nice neighborhood and it was intended to be as an investment (apartments for rent) and also to be used by me and my other brothers and sisters in the future. I am the eldest son and the only one having a job in our family at the time. So, I joined the project and started to send the majority of my monthly paycheck to my father for the building and development expenses. I was happy I am actually helping out the whole family.
Four years later when my father project completed I decided to quit my overseas job and return back to my country. I thought, well, now I have a nice apartment to live in and I can actually get married and start a personal business in my country instead. That was my plan basically. Only then when the problems started to arise. My father told me some terrible news. He said he built the building with his retirement money while my own money which I was sending him for years are available for me and I can go to the bank to get it. Period. Basically he told me that the building project was his while my money is mine! Not a major problem in normal circumstances but in my case my country was going through its toughest economic collapse; My country, Sudan, splitted into two countries after a long-term war, and our national currency became useless when exchanged to foreign currencies. Not only that. When I checked the bank account that my father used to manage I found what I assumed to be less than 25% of the actual money I transfered to my father over four years of my employment overseas! Unfortunately and because I had an absolute trust on my father I never actually wrote anything down. I was sending him the majority of my paycheck, thousands of dollars every month, but never took any notes. No bank statements to refer to; No clue how much EXACTLY I was sending him. At the end, my saving money on my father hands became of little value and I failed to buy a house or even a car of my own. I could not marry yet. For me that was not just a big disappointment but a disaster in and of itself.
Of course I had a discussion with my father. I argued a lot. BIG TIME. I told him why you didn’t tell me about your retirement money in the first place. I thought he is receiving a monthly pension, not a one-time big retirement cash. I questioned him why he kept calling me overseas and requesting my money to be transfered to him for the building project if he already had enough money to do it. I sadly said to him, well, now my money has lost its value because of the economic situation and because it was simply sitting in the bank for four years without investing it. If I knew I would have invested it somewhere somehow. The result of my argument with my father was absolutely nothing. I did not mention the fact that my money is supposed to be fourfold that amount; I though that kind of loud accusation from a son to his father would simply destroy our relationship forever; I didn’t want to hurt his feelings anymore since he has health issues. For me, I just concluded that my father has unintentionally failed me and that he didn’t mean to do all that to me. I convinced myself the hard way that the rest of my money, nearly 75% of it, was already spent in the building project and other family expenses like my brothers/sisters school and college fees etc etc which is OK with me if my father knowledged it. I just decided to move on. To forget it all. I was deeply wounded and heart-broken that my four years of hard work overseas resulted in nothing because of my father; not even a thank-you; but I sincerely decided to suck it in and just let it go.
All that was three years ago when I returned back home from my overseas job. But.. Just recently, like last month, my father was chatting with me and he actually told me that he’s got a huge sum of money in his investment bank account. About 500,000 U.S dollars! He never tells me before about his financial status EVER. Why now? From where? What is the source of that money? If he built his multi-story building from his retirement money then from where did he get half a million dollar now?
I know how much his retirement money was. I know how much the building cost. I know how much he earns from renting apartments. I know he has no other sources of income. Yet when it comes to the $500,000 I can’t assume anything except its my own money – the money I earned from my overseas job after it was invested for years and years. I even know the fact that his investment bank gives about 18% profit-rate annually, so whatever the initial deposit was it would increase fast over the years.
Honestly I have not yet open a new discussion with my father about his new secret treasure; I know that discussing money issues with him will drive me crazy because he simply does not care. He is cold as ice. He wants to be seen as the owner of everything and the provider of the family, not me. Its almost a month now and I can’t even sleep properly; I rarely eat; Last week I was held in a hospital for hours because of dehydration and they gave me several bags/drips through the vein; I keep asking myself questions that only my father is suppose to answer; why did you do that to me? why did you steal my money? why didn’t you ask yourself one day one question about your whole financial situation? why you suddenly became rich after you retired at the age of 60? is it even possible that you don’t know you have my money? should I go big and start a fight? go to the police? complain to other family members like his mom and brothers and create a mess? should I just move on AGAIN and just disappear and never meet my father and the whole family altogether? should I forgive him and forget it all for the second time although the picture is 100% clear now and its just a matter of simple math and basic calculation? Does even forgiveness in something like that possible?!
For the first time in my life I started to HATE my father. I know its terrible to say that especially in my country where people will automatically judge you and call you a bad son or daughter who does not respect their father! Well, I have being respecting and trusting my father with my life, my whole life, by I can’t take it anymore. Deep inside I know its not an issue of money but an issue of trust in the first place. Deep inside I know that even if he admitted his fault and gave me all my money back after all these years I would still not trust or respect him again. The damage is already done, and the broken glass can never be fixed.
Any words of advice, ideas, or even condolences would be greatly appreciated.
Thank you for your time.
October 2, 2016 at 11:09 am #116935AnonymousGuestDear Samir:
The pain of betrayal. It is a heavy pain. And you are suffering this pain. Shame is on your father for hurting you as badly as he did. My empathy is with you, the victim of this ongoing crime.
Regarding forgiving him: if he didn’t ask for forgiveness AND did not offer to make amends, financial amends and then proceeded to make them all the way- what would be the basis for considering forgiving him?
It wouldn’t be wise to forgive him and put your trust in him again, would it? Denying the reality of what happened and what is happening is the road to disaster for you. Reality does not accommodate the denial of it.
It wouldn’t be possible for you to have peace-of-mind if you forgive him and continue to watch him benefiting from his crime against you. How can you forgive a person for stabbing you while he continues to stab you? How do you stop bleeding?
If I was you, I would do anything I can to legally get a hold of those $500,000. You can unearth bank records of your financial transfers through the years. I don’t know if there is a way for you to legally go for that money. Maybe consult an attorney. During such and afterwards, I would cut all contact with him.
When a man (your father) betrays his own son year after year, never to apologize, never to make amends- financial amends in this case- well, let him receive the natural and reasonable consequence that he earned: losing his son’s trust, esteem, affection and contact.
Get any part of your money if legally possible; then cut your losses and move far away.
October 2, 2016 at 1:39 pm #116955pink24ParticipantHi Sam,
I completely relate to you. I am Middle Eastern too, and have similar issues of dishonesty and betrayal with my mother. It’s very hard to reconcile what the culture demands of us in terms of respecting our parents, and our own experience with them. But as adults it’s our own experience we have to go with–no matter what the cost.
If I can give you a bit of advice that has worked for me–do cut off all ties with your father. Distance yourself from your family. Save yourself. You’re the only one who will. That within itself is disappointing, since we’re Middle Eastern and family is supposed to be everything, but it’s the truth.
Forge your own path in this life. With your own ideals. Your father has his issues, yes. But they are not yours.
Good luck 🙂
Pink
October 2, 2016 at 3:45 pm #116958SamParticipantDear Anita,
Thank you for your kind support and empathy, not just with me but with many others in this website. You’re blessed.Back to my story, I agree with you regarding forgiveness. I already forgave my father the first time three years ago, but now after he admitted he has a secret bank account with $500,000 I simply can’t just go blind again. Its impossible and out-of-question. It would be self-destruction and even weakness of me. My money is out there and I can’t get it. No forgiveness, but I wish I could just forget it and wipe it off my mind! Not even that possible!
The problem is: legal actions is impossible for me. Yes he is my father and yes he taken my money to his own benefits, but to take legal actions against him is a red-line. Honestly I thought about it for sometime but I came to the concultion that it would do more harm than good. He might die from the shock and sadness alone, and everyone will put it on my shoulders.
I am thinking about confrontation! To show him that I know everything. That is my main go-plan for now, but even that plan may go badly for both me and him. Why? Because of our damn middle-eastern culture — everyone will stand by my father side against me regardless of the facts simply because he is the father and I am the son.. Its very common here to hear the words: (“Come on, he is your father for God’s sake; don’t you have morals? he is the man who brought you to life and raised you as a child; he can anytime to you and you simply shut-up”)!! Even my father know that he is happily assured of his safety, thanks to our environment and culture.
Yet, my major concern is, even if I go BIG and get my money back that would not get me my loving father back anyway.. I lost him already, and he will loose me too. Ass of me and because of my hurt right now I can say with absoule certainty: I DON’T CARE.. I don’t care what my father would think, and I don’t care what the people would think — But I very much care for my mother, brothers and sisters feelings and well-being. I am already avoiding and limiting contact with my father but I don’t see a way of cutting contact completely without losing the whole family too. It is a terrible situation.
What do you think Anita?
Thank you.October 2, 2016 at 4:02 pm #116959SamParticipantHi Pink24,
Thanks a lot for your kind words and I am sorry you experienced something similar with your mother, in the same middle-eastern culture.Regarding your advice, I am already in a very limited contact with my father although we live under the same roof; I kept avoiding him during the last few years; I haven’t spoken with him this month at all since he told me he has my money; of course he didn’t say its my money but you get the point.
I already asked Anita this question but I would love to hear your viewpoint too: should I go BIG and confront my father, perhaps invite some close family members to join-in in resolving this situation, and then if things went wrong I can, well, take my own separate path in life like you said? Any ideas on that? If you don’t mind sharing, how cutting off all ties with your own mother helped you and to what extend?
Once more thank a lot.
October 2, 2016 at 9:16 pm #116976AnonymousGuestDear Sam:
I need to read your later posts more attentively, in ten hours or so (tomorrow morning)- will write to you then.
anita
October 3, 2016 at 1:12 am #116981XenopusTexParticipantAh, blind trust. Sometimes the ones closest to you are the ones who will screw you over the most. I too made the mistake of trusting family. That taught me to trust nobody.
My guess is that you probably won’t see any of that money.
October 3, 2016 at 3:15 am #116985SamParticipantAnita:
Thanks. Take all the time you need and I’m waiting.XenopusTex:
Thanks. You put it clear and right; it was really “blind trust”.October 3, 2016 at 7:22 am #116991pink24ParticipantHi Sam,
Go big or go home. Yes, confront your father. BUT, and I say this from experience—be prepared for him NOT to give you the answers you need and deserve. Confronting him is more for you to just have the truth out there, you know? Not for him to choose to spin it his way. Unless his explanation would make a difference to you. Would it? From your post I don’t think so…
Since you asked, I completely cut off all communication for my mother and consequently my father too (who is kind and sweet so that was hard) several years ago for an entire year. That was a big deal for me. I live about an hour away, not under the same roof as you, so I can only imagine what you must feel. I’m sorry you are going through this.
Cutting them off at that time was the best thing for me. I needed to just get away from all of the toxicity and deceit. Kind of purify myself. Not that that was my intention, but that is what wound up happening. It was the best year of my life.
Fast forward–After that year, I initiated a relationship with them, on different ground this time. I had boundaries, which I didn’t have before. And it was ok for awhile. But unfortunately, the trust issue came up again in a different scenario. Although I wasn’t as hurt and pained–I was hurt, but not to the extent as I was the first time– I questioned why my mother was even in my life if I can’t trust anything she says? This world is tough enough without such difficulties, as I’m sure you know.
Does that make sense? It’s just really hard to have a relationship with a parent without trust. Even though I no longer speak with them, my parents do know I will be there for them in crisis, or if they ever needed anything. And I say this because I’ve been so careful not to say anything damning to them. Maybe that’s the Middle Eastern in me. But I don’t want regrets.
Does that help?
October 3, 2016 at 8:49 am #116994AnonymousGuestDear Sam:
Thank you for your comment about me.
Your father has been on a crime spree against you for seven years and going, fearlessly and shamelessly. Society stands by him because of his position: father. No legal or practical consequences for him. In a society like this Power is everything and he has the power.
There is nothing admirable about a family and a society where Power is value # 1, and Justice is a non-issue.
You were and are a victim of a crime: theft, grand theft. Your work of four years has been, in effect, slave labor.
Your mother and siblings will choose your father over you during the confrontation you are thinking about. Because Power is what it is all about.
Now that you are where you are, placed in a spot of weakness, helplessness, powerlessness-
Do you have a choice: to stay there or to leave?
Your mother and siblings will choose your father in a confrontation (and at best, in private, will express some empathy to you, out of your father’s vision). Hopefully, they will benefit from your slave labor as your father may use your money for their well being; hopefully he will leave it as inheritance when he dies.
When your father stole from you for four years and then doesn’t let you have enough of YOUR hard earned money so you can have a decent life in Sudan, he expressed what value you have in his mind and heart. Do you accept that value as indeed, your value?
There is nothing noble or admirable in respecting a family and a society governed by power, not by justice.
Looking forward to read from you next.
anita
October 3, 2016 at 1:54 pm #117080SamParticipantHi Pink24,
OMG! Your story is just a copy of mine with little differences! I also cut off all ties with my father two years ago but only for a short time. I went to India for business/study for just 3 months and never called my father and the whole family during that period ever, for the first time ever. I disconnected myself completely. It wasn’t something easy or normal for me and them since whenever and wherever I travel I used to call them every week just to say hi and salaam alykom. But I was very angry with my father again (due to other issues, not the major story I wrote above). When I came back home 3 months later I confronted my father about those issues and also told his mother, my grandmother, about how badly he was treating me. Fortunately, my grandmother stood by my side against my father and actually got very angry with him; she even told him something bold like (if you don’t treat your son right, you’re not my son anymore)! It was big, and my father shocked and apologized to me, and I agreed to open a new page with him after I laid down rules to govern our relationships (Dos and Don’ts — just like children). Yet, like in your own story Pink, trust issues came up again shortly after that day, and I thought, well, nothing changed or will ever change with my father.Its difficult with our society and families and I totally agree with your words: “This world is tough enough without such difficulties”.
Anyway, good for you that you ended it smoothly and smartly yet also made yourself available for them if they ever need you. That’s beautiful. I wonder like crazy if I could do the same!
Thank you Pink. Your words were indeed helpful.
October 3, 2016 at 3:16 pm #117095SamParticipantHi Anita,
Thanks for returning back.You put it right — it was definitely and sadly four years of slave labor thanks to my father. It’s beyond sad. It’s terrible and horrible. You know I wished he never mentioned his secret treasure to me last month and remind me of something I forgot — or trying to forget — for the last three years. Sometimes the dark is better than this kind of ugly truth.
I get strange feelings that he is trying to provoke or irritate me, otherwise why the hell he reminds me of his or my money now after we closed this subject years ago.And yes I know, my mother and siblings do and will always stand by my father against me regardless of the facts. It happened before and I no longer blame them or try to put any heavy weight on their shoulders. Rarely they show empathy if any; sometimes they even accuse me of attempting to destroy the family, not knowing what good I secretly did over the years to support and protect the family.
Regardless of anything I am planning to confront my father before I go away and distance myself from the whole family, but I will not go without declaring the reason of me going! I will tell the family that my father has lied to me for years and he has my money of $500,000 — good for you all — and that is the last of what I can provide to this non-supportive family. Oh, Anita, some might die from these shocking words but what else I can do! I can forget but never forgive again, and I definitely can’t keep it inside of me anymore. Enough is enough.
Thank you for your time.
October 3, 2016 at 3:30 pm #117098AnonymousGuestDear Sam:
I hope your father will not physically hurt you if you confront him in front of the rest of the family. He felt entitled to steal from you. He may even be bitter that you were able to make more money than he did- he may be jealous of you! He may be pleased to have depleted you of the advantage of the education you have and he doesn’t; of the money you were able to earn and he didn’t.
If you confront him in front of the others, he may be so enraged. Unless you are able to protect yourself physically- I am worried about your personal safety. Your father is not a good man and society will defend him. He is not afraid of social retribution- he may proceed to defeat you not only financially, as he has done, but maim you or even kill you.
Please be careful. You wrote that you are a software architect. Can you arrange to work overseas again, make good money again and this time, keep all of it?
Consider not confronting while you are vulnerable to your father physically attacking you. Confront him once you are not physically present, from a distance?
anita
October 4, 2016 at 1:31 am #117127SamParticipantHello again Anita,
I don’t think he can physically hurt me; he is a weak old man who surfer from some health issues. I am not worried about him hurting me; I am worried about me hurting him verbally and emotionally — because I will tell him what he hates to hear, including that he was jealous of me and my higher education and my money and everything I achieved during my 20s and 30s and he failed to achieve during his entire life.I will protect myself from him. BTW he knows that I am strong and actually very logical and reasonable during tough conversations and confrontations; I am not afraid of anybody; A lot of people see me as a charismatic self-confident man and rely on me to help them out in their own problems. Two years ago when I confronted my father with his mother (please refer to my post to Pink24 above), he almost break-down and cried and said sorry to me.
I haven’t mentioned the details of that in my post to @Pink24 above but let me briefly say it now just to get it off my chest anyway.. Two years ago my father angrily told me that Mr. ABC (who is a good friend of our family) has told him that your son Sam (me) is having an illegal affair with many bad girls! Just like that! I was not having such affairs and I considered it as an attack on my reputation and social image, so I asked my father: Did you believe Mr. ABC? and he said: (Yes I do, he is my best friend and he is an old gentleman who never tell lies).. So I went over and confronted Mr. ABC face-to-face, and to my shock he denied the whole story altogether. I wished to die that day! I really wished so! MY FATHER IS A LIAR AND HE IS TRYING TO DESTROY MY LIFE. I asked Mr. ABC to confront my father back which he thankfully did and rebuked him badly. My father felt ashamed but did not attempt to say sorry to me.. So I escalated the subject to his mother, my grandmother, and told her the whole story. She loves me without limits, so she stood by my side against her son, my father, and she actually warned him that he is not her son anymore if he do not fix this with me. Ultimately my father found himself in a tight corner and apologized to me and shed a few tears.
Back to you Anita, Yes I can easily get a job overseas again and I don’t see an issue on that. I have a master degree in Information Systems Technology and a solid work experience in software development in top companies including Oracle — a giant American corporation.
To sum up, I think my father’s weak point now is that past experience of Mr. ABC and all its witnesses including his mom, but his main strong point right now would be that I am financially broke and hence I am trying to blackmail him or something! That is expected from him, so as a precaution I may consider confronting him after I get a job overseas again — which I am expecting to happen soon. Its complicated.
Thank you Anita
October 4, 2016 at 10:08 am #117160AnonymousGuestDear Sam:
Your father’s mother is still alive- I hope I didn’t miss this information in your posts: did you tell her about her son stealing your money? And can she side with you against him and… get that money back to you (that would be more beneficial to you than the empty apology her previous confrontation with him brought about).
Your father may be “a weak old man who surfer from some health issues” and you may be ” strong and actually very logical and reasonable during tough conversations and confrontations…not afraid of anybody.. charismatic self-confident man” but in the context of your relationship with your father, he was not afraid of you. He was not afraid to steal from you for years; not afraid of how you would respond. In his mind, you were and are still the weak one and therefore easily exploitable.
I do hope you get another job overseas soon, that you make money and send none of it to any member of your family (they got enough of it!), and make a good life for yourself away from the man who turned against his own son long ago.
anita
-
AuthorPosts