fbpx
Menu

cutting back cut offs

HomeForumsRelationshipscutting back cut offs

New Reply
Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #111667
    flyby
    Participant

    I am having problems understanding the concept of cutting people out of your life to feel better about yourself. I was raised to be loyal and compassionate with those I cherished. While I have not been cut out of any ones life as toxic, there have been many people I cut out of my life because I perceived them as toxic. Why did I do this? Possibly my own insecurity and need for positive insulation.
    Or one to many self help solutions that convinced me this is how to handle relationships.
    Looking back, I think this was an incredibly selfish and self centered. Really who was I to say :sorry you just aren’t working for me right now and I don’t really want to compromise my *current* state of well being to deal with any threat of negativity. Some of these relationships were repaired to better order, while others were repaired but never quite the same. At the same time others continued to be an actual toxic situation that I should have continued to keep clear of.
    My point in this post is to say, maybe stop trying to isolate yourself in a world of positivity and only positive people. If someone is ‘toxic’, maybe really think about what that means, and if this person could use compassion and loyalty rather than judgement and dismissal. We are all in this life together and setting up boundaries is a better option. If those boundaries are respected, then I don’t think you can rightfully cut off the friendship just because it isn’t working for you. If those boundaries are not respected, I personally believe this is when the cut off should occur.

    #111669
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear flyby:

    Welcome back!

    As to your suggestion: “stop trying to isolate yourself in a world of positivity and only positive people”- one would be alone, not even in one own company. Who is positive all the time? (And it is an unreasonable pressure to put on oneself, to say and act positive at all times)

    You wrote: ” If someone is ‘toxic’, maybe really think about what that means”- I agree: define what is “toxic”. It is okay and reasonable that any person will be negative at times, pessimistic, sad. No emotions should be rejected as bad or negative and a person should not pretend to not have these feelings. All feelings have valid messages, all are needed, all therefore are positive.

    “Toxic” means poisonous, harmful. If a friend is sad and that makes me feel sad too, that wouldn’t be a reason for me to leave that person, to cut contact. It would be a reason for me to comfort the person, to spend more time with the person. But if the person is sad and abusive (aka toxic) and yells at me, blaming me for what I am not responsible for, letting off steam that way, then that is a different story.

    Loyalty to a person who harms you is self defeating, and a disloyalty to yourself. Loyalty to a person who is loving and respectful of you and yet sad, depressed, anxious is admirable. In the latter case, I would be compassionate to the person best I can and at the same time take the breaks I need so to not exhaust myself. Always care for yourself first.

    anita

    #111677
    flyby
    Participant

    Glad to be back.
    Thanks for your insight on how to think about ‘toxic’. I definitely try not to throw it around as much as I used to. For example in past posts I mentioned a past friend/lover who definitely was toxic after many years of trying to convince myself otherwise. On the other hand I’ve had a friend struggling with addiction and depression who I perceived as toxic, but who really just needed someone to care. Happy to report the former is out of my life nearly a year, and the latter has after an intervention taken steps to improve upon her life and is a joy to have around.
    That said I do regret rushing to judgement on others in the past just because I wasn’t willing/strong enough at the time to really consider the entire situation. Sometimes it just seems so easy when you read posts on how to cleanse your life of negativity, but as you mentioned, negativity doesn’t mean intentionally hurtful.

    #111678
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear flyby:

    Glad the first is out of your life and the second has improved and is a joy to have around.

    Your last line: “Negativity doesn’t mean intentionally hurtful”- not what I said and I want to explain why I wouldn’t say this: let’s say a person calls you horrible names, even hits you and then says: I didn’t intend to hurt you. I was just so distressed. I have a bi polar diagnosis. Etc. Just an example.

    This person in my example is abusive regardless of intention and shouldn’t be in your life.

    But there is more to it: when a person acts abusively toward another, unless the person is totally unaware of reality, that is the person is in full fledged psychotic episode, then the person does intend to hurt. It is the hurting act itself, the calling names, the hitting, that relieves the abuser’s distress, making him or her feel better.

    So the “I didn’t mean to hurt you…” or “It was not my intention to hurt you..” following abusive behavior is really a lie. It makes the person saying it feel better, but it is not true.

    anita

    #111726
    flyby
    Participant

    As someone who dated a physically abusive bipolar partner 4 years ago, I completely understand what you are saying. It reminds me of the phrase, “i’m sorry that you” which is again something that escapes responsibility and unfairly puts it back on you as the problem. I didn’t realize intent is something so hard to accept about ones own actions.

    Also of interest. When you say that a person may be totally unaware of reality… I’ve found several situations throughout my life when this has happened. I dont understand how someone can be unaware of reality even when I’ve gently, not forcefully, tried to make them aware when there are obvious issues for concern.

    For example a good friend and roommate in college had a boyfriend who cheated on her regularly and it got to a point where everyone knew this. I tried to express this to her, but ultimately she went back to him and stopped speaking to me until after they broke up. Similarly I had a friend who called me several years ago under the influence of something, so bad I was concerned for her safety. After making sure she was going to be okay, I reached out to her brother for help. She never called me or spoke to me again. As a third example, a friend was physically abusive to her husband… this time I said nothing, but she later mentioned the two of them were fine and weren’t going to acknowledge it. I never really understand how one looks past these things which I personally believe is cause for concern. Ultimately I just keep out of it, even though I still acknowledge it, at least to myself.

    #111727
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear flyby:

    Interesting you lived the reality of my example.

    By a totally unaware, in the midst of a psychotic episode I mean someone who will commit a crime in front of a police officer standing right there, not being aware of one’s actions and consequences. Not being able to remember the episode later. This is uncommon.

    What you are writing about is the common version of not being aware. There is some awareness though. In my example of committing a criminal act in front of a police officer, it would be a person committing a crime near a police station because of being impulsive and “having to” do it but hoping to get away, hoping no one is watching. There is a memory of the incident later.

    Other than criminality, limited awareness is the norm. Who is completely aware? One in a billion people, perhaps. I am becoming more and more aware and there is always, so far, more for me to become aware of. And we are often aware of the unawareness of others in their personal lives while remaining limited in our awareness of our own personal lives.

    People see what they want to see; they don’t see what they don’t want to see. This is business as usual and it is so when seeing what-is brings about anxiety. And we will do anything to avoid the awareness of fear. So we close our eyes and pretend the monster is not there.

    Awareness is a wonderful thing, amazing, invigorating, if one can handle the fear involved.

    More of your thoughts? Anytime. I like this correspondence.

    anita

    #111730
    flyby
    Participant

    I guess I’m also my own example here. Being in the 20 year relationship that was repeatedly hurtful and unsuccessful I chose to see only the hope of improvement, when there was overwhelming evidence that it wasn’t going anywhere but hurt. Previously you had mentioned this may have been a reason for my anger (post from a while ago), as it was trying to relay this message to me. The same was true when I was in the abusive bipolar relationship. In that case however I was so determined to get away from the 20 year guy’s cycle I ignored the indications of his personality disorder even though I was well aware of what his medications were prescribed for and what his behavior was indicative of. I certainly had the flight signal blaring out loud, but I stayed and ended up in the fight instead.

    So yes, I remember all of these things and denying that voice that knows better. Its also a reason why I try not to get involved in other people’s situations even if I feel like they need some kind of enlightenment.

    Recently I’ve been trying to understand guilt and ultimately shame. I mentioned feeling these briefly as this guy of 20 years displaced his personal guilt and shame on me, even though I personally had never felt it before. I’m happy to say now free of him, I dont feel these things about myself or actions as they were never really mine. However the more I try to understand these concepts the more it seems common place for people to carry deeply rooted guilt and shame that have huge effects on their behavior and actions towards others.

    I had a wonderful early education at a school (13 years of it) that really taught us to understand all sides of a story, regardless if we agreed with them or not. I remember being seriously defensive of my opinions in my early adolescence, then after some great teaching, I have always been aware of thoughts from other peoples perspectives. My own was always subject to change the more aware I became. So it is difficult to see people unaware or becoming aware so much later on after other issues arise from it.

    It still difficult for me to fully understand guilt and shame, but its something I wish i knew how to deal with when it comes up as people become more aware of theirs. I feel like you must face those things to move on, but at the same time it seems so easy to let them stew below the surface. I wish I knew how to recognize if one is carrying shame especially. I feel if it isn’t something they can become aware of it just gets thrown on to someone else.

    #111734
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear flyby:

    What stands between a person and awareness of one own life is anxiety. When a person desperately needs to feel love, so to comfort the anxiety (excess, ongoing fear), then a person will make believe anything that remotely resembles an appearance of love, is indeed love and ignore all the evidence otherwise. This unawareness is usually (if not always) not complete so the person is often distressed anyway, maybe a lower grade distress than the distress of overwhelming anxiety.

    So when I see another person unaware of their situation, I now understand: it is not a person’s lack of intelligence, it is what we all automatically do: move our awareness away from anxiety, from fear. This is why when dealing with others and with ourselves we have to apply a lot of gentleness and patience.

    As to shame and guilt- this is why people mistreat themselves. And often, people with that accusatory, abusive Inner Critic take a break from their own Inner Critic and accuse and abuse others. The abusive Inner Critic who points shame and guilt at oneself has its other side of the coin companion, the abusive Outer Critic, accusing and shaming others.

    People who abuse themselves take breaks and abuse others. Then back to abusing themselves, the distress intensifies, the need a relief and the relief is in abusing another. Maybe some people skip all together the Inner Critic cycle and … specialize in the Outer Critic dynamic exclusively.

    Shame is very painful. I think it is the most painful emotion while fear is the most powerful. People will endure shame but fear, this is what people will do ANYTHING to avoid.

    anita

    #111737
    flyby
    Participant

    Thanks anita. That really helps connect some concepts in my head. Im really trying to better understand terms and how they apply to people and myself rather than just using them and throwing them out there as descriptors of emotion So far I have come to better understand in no particular order
    Value
    Worth
    Anger
    Acceptance
    Toxic
    Shame
    Guilt

    Fear amd its relationship to anxiety is something else to look into as well for understanding.

    • This reply was modified 8 years, 3 months ago by flyby.
    • This reply was modified 8 years, 3 months ago by flyby.
    #111742
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear flyby:

    I define anxiety as excessive, ongoing fear. It is clear to me that anxiety is in the core of most clusters of symptoms, that is diagnoses of mental disorders. It is the root cause. It often happens in childhood that the child is overwhelmed by fear, repeatedly, not comforted and so the brain shuts down to various degrees, dissociation takes place and that excess energy of fear releases itself in forms of tics (Tourette Syndrome for one), compulsions (OCD)

    It is only these days that I am having memories of childhood that I didn’t have before. Things like the look of a notebook in school, the feel of going to school on the first day, short flashes of such. I was very dissociated my whole life.

    anita

    #111749
    XenopusTex
    Participant

    Anita, I would amend the fear comment. Short term, fear is a very powerful motivator. Long term, fear can lose its effect. For example, fear of failing is used a lot in schools. It was very powerful at times in law school. Then learned that the school applied a strict C curve. That means if everybody scores 100% there is a handful of A’ and a handful of F’s and everybody else in the middle. The result would be the same for everyone handing in a blank sheet of paper. Fear as a motivator long term tends to lead to apathy.

    I made the mistake of letting a toxic person back into my life and have felt lots of pain as a result. Some would say I am toxic. Maybe that’s why my relationships suck.

    #111759
    Anonymous
    Guest

    * Dear XenopusTex: since the original poster on this thread is flyby, I respond only to the posts by the original poster, so not to start a multi-member discussion on any thread. If you’d like to discuss fear with someone other than the original poster here, you can bring up the last thread you started (it was about fear) or start a new one.
    anita

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.