fbpx
Menu

Boyfriend is depressed (I think) and broke up with me

Home→Forums→Relationships→Boyfriend is depressed (I think) and broke up with me

New Reply
Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #197455
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Hailie:

    I would like to understand better, therefore I ask:

    You wrote, “We were arguing a little more than normal recently”- how often did you argue in the past, who initiated arguments and what were they about? What words were used during such arguments by you and by him?

    And recently…?

    anita

    #197457
    Hailie
    Participant

    We didn’t really argue that much in general. It was never over anything big. Just little disagreements I guess I would call them. Most of the time it was one of us overreacting to something the other one said, or interpreting it the wrong way, or one of us would be feeling insecure about something. And we never yelled at each other, put each other down or anything like that. We would both explain what we were feeling and then resolve it in a timely manner. He said he felt that we weren’t resolving things and were arguing over the same thing, which i’m not really sure what he’s referring to. A lot of the time they would turn into a bigger deal because he would react by saying “I’m just the worst” or “you should just break up with me because I’m shitty and you shouldn’t settle for that” which would then make me more frustrated because I never said any of those things, and that’s not what I wanted. So I guess that was one of the main things we would argue about. Not even the thing that upset us in the first place – but how he would react to it.

     

    #197465
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Hailie:

    Can you give me an example of he said/he said of an argument. It doesn’t need to be exact, of course. An example of a significant argument that took place?

    anita

    #197469
    Anonymous
    Guest

    * didn’t reflect under Topics

    #197473
    Hailie
    Participant

    So a few weeks ago he brought up that he could talk to his manager and ask if they were hiring so that i could apply. This was right after I lost the job ( that I really loved) So I just told him that “That’s a really good idea and i really appreciate you trying to help I’m just not sure if that would be somewhere I would want to work right now” and he said “I should just stop trying to help because I can’t help or make you feel better” and then didn’t respond for an hour or so. and then started saying how ” I should just break up with him because he’s just shitty and can’t make me happy so I probably just want to break up with him, etc.” I asked him if that is what he wants and he said “no not at all. i guess I’m just convincing myself that you do.” Just things like that, both of us overreacting and letting our insecurities get in the way. But again, we resolved it, at least i thought. but maybe to him we didn’t? because he still thought he just couldn’t make me happy or feel better

    #197475
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Hailie:

    In the example you gave, I failed to see your overreaction. Where is it? Also, I read frustration on his part, I fail to see anger or frustration on your part, where is it? Nor do I read you disagreeing with him.

    (If there was none, no anger on your part expressed, no frustration, not even disagreement on your part, there was no argument. It takes two to argue).

    anita

    #197483
    Hailie
    Participant

    I didn’t overreact in this case. I think what would happen was he was just making a problem out of nothing, and then I would get kind of frustrated. Or I felt like instead of focusing on the main problem, or the thing I was upset about, he would turn it in to ā€œ oh I’m just the worstā€ which made it hard to really get all of my feelings out there.

    #197487
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Hallie:

    regarding this example, assuming prior to that verbal exchange you did not complain to him a lot about having lost your job, not going on and on about it (leading him to come up with his suggested solution), then from the information you provided, reads like you are reasonable and he is unreasonable, or has become unreasonable (if he wasn’t before), making a functional relationship impossible.

    anita

    #197489
    Hailie
    Participant

    Maybe a better example would be about a week ago he was hanging out with one of his friends that he hasn’t seen in a while. I told him that I would text him later to let him have time to just hang out with that friend. And he got upset because he thought I was saying I just wanted him to leave me alone, which is been a problem in the past. Because I have said oh I’ll just leave you alone when I felt like I was interrupting something he was doing. But I texted him back saying that’s not what I meant and that’s not what I wanted, but he continued to just ignore me for a few hours. When he finally responded I told him I was upset that he didn’t text me back or at least acknowledge the fact that I told him I didn’t want him to just leave me alone. He then got defensive saying that whenever I said that, he was hard for him to understand what I actually wanted. To which again I said, but I texted you saying I didn’t mean I wanted you to leave me alone. Ā So just stupid little stuff like that. None of our arguments, or whatever I should call them, we’re over anything big or serious.

    #197499
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Hailie:

    Will be back to the computer in about 15 hours. Will reply when I am back. If you would like to add any more information that may be relevant by then, please do. I hope other members will reply to you before my return.

    anita

    #197513
    Hailie
    Participant

    I also wanted to add something about when we would argue/ when i would be upset about something. Whenever I would get upset about something, even if it wasn’t a huge deal, he would as I said go straight to just blaming himself and say he is the worst. but he would also often times hit himself in the head, really hard, over and over. I know this is not healthy. And i am so upset at myself for not telling someone about this – but i didn’t know what to do i guess. But anyways, he would do that, sometimes hit the wall or throw things ( not at me) and would lock himself in another room where I could not get to him. At one point ( I don’t remember what the problem was) he began to hold his breath for long periods of time, to the point where it seemed he would be close to passing out. All of this happened when me, or someone else in his life, was upset at him. Even as I’m writing this i’m feeling so horrible about not letting someone know this was happening, because i know how unhealthy it is that he is doing this. but i felt it might explain the situation more, so I wanted to mention that.

    #197589
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Hailie:

    What is clear to me is that this man was mistreated when he was a child, given the message that he was a bad boy, the worst, all those things he has been accusing himself of being. He was told those things.

    What is unclear to me is whether you were honest with him about your anger toward him or not. For example, when you told him that you will leave him alone so that he can spend time with his friend, whether you were okay with leaving him alone, or it was said angrily. I don’t know if you said it before, and knew from past experience that it will upset him to hear it, and yet you said it, being passive aggressive that way.

    He carries things from childhood, no doubt, and is inclined to see offense where there is none. Problem is, there are people (in addition to his parent/s) who are offensive, who are aggressive, passive aggressive if not directly aggressive. So sometimes he is correct about his present evaluation of people’s intent. Sometimes people do try to hurt others.

    Question is: when you are upset or frustrated, do you resort to saying things to hurt him, indirectly if not directly. I don’t know.

    anita

    #197625
    Hailie
    Participant

    I think when I would say this in the past it would be coming from a place of me being insecure that I SHOULD leave him alone, because he’s doing something else, or hanging out with someone else, and I don’t want to interrupt. It was also maybe a way to get reassurance that he did want to talk to me. which is dumb, because i should’ve know he did if he was talking to me, But in this case I truly did just mean what i said, which i explained to him, But i can see how it would be confusing for him.

    Thank you so much for responding to this, I really appreciate it!

    #197631
    Anonymous
    Guest

    Dear Hailie:

    You are very welcome. I don’t think he can handle any ambiguity from a person in an intimate relationship, or otherwise. He has to know that you mean what you say and say what you mean. Otherwise, he will be lost in torture because of the thoughts he has, thoughts that get activated when he encounters ambiguity.

    These thoughts are that he is the worst, a bad person, needs to be punished and so forth.

    anita

    #197749
    luminary22
    Participant

    Hi Hailie,

    No two situations are the same but yours sure does sound very similar to what has just happened to me as well the other day. He split up with me completely out of the blue after a day of being affectionate and caring, broke down crying saying he needs to “fix himself” before he is in a relationship with anyone. It came as a complete shock so I understand how you are feeling. He also never really opened up to me about what was really wrong however much I tried to help. I can’t really help much as I’m in the same predicament but all I can say (which I am also telling myself) is please don’t blame yourself or think that it is anything you have done. Easier said than done, I know. It’s a very sad situation to be in – I hope he gets the help he needs and that you are not too damaged by this happening to you.

    P

    x

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 16 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Please log in OR register.